BY ROY ALBERT ANDRADE, K1LLER, Inc.
MURFREESBORO, TENNESSEE - On May 27, 2016, then Rutherford County Sheriff, Robert Arnold, Chief Deputy Joe L. Russell II, and Arnold's uncle, John Vanderveer, of Marietta, Georgia, entered a Nashville courtroom in handcuffs, and were charged in a 14-count indictment by a federal grand jury on bribery concerning federal programs, obstruction of justice, wire fraud, among other related charges. The indictment alleged that Arnold, and Russell II used their official positions to increase their income by indirectly re-selling electronic cigarettes to Rutherford County jail inmates through JailCigs, LLC (JailCigs), a start-up company they formed together. In 2015, JailCigs, earned an estimated $156,975 in revenue from Rutherford County jail inmates, which, doesn't include monies received from online sales from other resources.
Arnold, and Russell II welcomed their company's electronic cigarettes into the Rutherford County Jail as permissible items, and successfully managed cooperating jail employees to conduct business on their behalf while on county time. As a marketing strategy, JailCigs paid a $5 commission for every electronic cigarette sold in Rutherford County jail, and to other officials at other detention facilities willing to risk their livelihood to make some cash on the side. On April 17, 2015, Arnold's uncle, John Vanderveer, heard of a criminal investigation through media reports, and instructed one of JailCig's sales representatives to destroy evidence pertaining to their lucrative scheme. Arnold, and Russell II made false statements to the media, denying ownership of the business, and paying themselves commission payments that should have been paid to Rutherford County.
On January 18, 2017, former Rutherford County Sheriff Robert Arnold, then 40, pleaded guilty to federal charges, including fraud and corruption, reported Acting U.S. Attorney, Jack Smith, for the Middle District of Tennessee. “Today, Robert Arnold admitted his guilt and participation in the brazen criminal scheme charged in the indictment brought against him by the grand jury,” reported Acting U.S. Attorney Jack Smith. “His guilty pleas hold him accountable for his criminal conduct and we look forward to the sentencing hearing in this matter. I would like to thank the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation and the FBI for their extraordinary work in investigating this case. I’d also like to thank District Attorney General Jennings Jones for his assistance and cooperation, as well as the Department of Justice’s Public Integrity Section, who partnered with us on the prosecution of this case. As I have said in the past, the conduct of Arnold is in no way representative of the fine and often heroic work done daily by the law enforcement officers in our district. Finally, let me thank the citizens of Rutherford County for their patience while waiting for justice to be served in this case.”
Arnold pleaded guilty to honest services fraud, wire fraud, and extortion under color of official right. He agreed to pay restitution in the amount of $52,500 to Rutherford County, and sentenced by Chief Judge Sharp on May 8, 2017 to 50 months in federal prison, forfeiting $66,790. “This plea is the result of the hard work by the men and women of the FBI and our law enforcement partners,” said Michael T. Gavin, Special Agent in Charge of the Memphis Division of the Federal Bureau of Investigation. “We all rely on those who hold positions of public trust to execute their duties with integrity and in the best interests of the public. The FBI will continue to work with its partners to identify and investigate law enforcement officers who violate the law out of personal greed, which harms the reputations of all law enforcement officers, the majority of which are honest, hardworking men and women who serve with honor, integrity, and professionalism.”
On September 6, 2017, Arnold's uncle, John Vanderveer, was sentenced to one year in federal prison for attempting to tamper with a key witness in the criminal investigation by ordering JailCig's sales representative to destroy incriminating documents related to the company's scheme. Vanderveer was ordered to pay $52,500 in restitution.
This morning, on November 16, 2017, former Rutherford County Sheriff's administrative Chief Deputy, Joe L. Russell II, was sentenced to 15 months in federal prison by Senior U.S District Judge Marvin Aspen of the Northern District of Illionois, and instructed to pay $52,500 in restitution, including the forfeiture of $52,234.41, equivalent to monetary amount he received from JailCigs, LLC.
Shawn W. Anderson
Jessica K. Mattingly
Roy Albert Andrade